NerdWallet analyzed rates from 18 insurers to find the cheapest car insurance companies in New York City.

2 days ago · The average rate in New York is $424/mo. Progressive offers the cheapest car insurance in New York at $242/mo. Compare quotes and save on auto insurance near you with The Zebra.

Dec 18, 2025 · To find the best cheap auto insurance in New York state, ValuePenguin collected quotes from the largest NY auto insurance companies across all ZIP codes in the state.

Nov 1, 2025 · New York has some of the highest average car insurance rates of any state — but car insurance costs in New York can look very different depending on which part of the state you...

Dec 8, 2025 · Here are the average premium costs for full and minimum coverage car insurance in New York: Source: Experian. Full coverage car insurance is usually required if your car is financed or …

Sep 10, 2025 · According to CarInsurance.com data, drivers in New York pay about $156 per month for full coverage car insurance. Understanding the average insurance cost can give you a head start in …

Dec 4, 2025 · Our research found that Progressive is the cheapest on average for drivers in the Empire State, followed by Kemper, USAA and Geico. How Much Car Insurance Do I Need in New York? Our...

Dec 13, 2025 · Find the best car insurance for you in New York today. How to Get the Best Car Insurance? Quick Take: What Is the Best Car Insurance for New York Drivers? Progressive is the …

Nov 12, 2025 · Progressive and NYCM have some of the cheapest rates in New York. The average cost of full coverage auto insurance in New York state is $2,279, which is similar to the national average …